Design Analysis Practice on the Class Blog

 I am wanting to use the class blog so the students can analyse each others design work and they can give feedback to each other. 

To get them comfortable with using the class blog for their work we have been uploading their work with description and explanations of what they have been doing - blog post here and blog post here

Next, we had a go at product analysis with structured questions - blog post here

This week we has our first go at analysing drawn designs for the seating project we are doing. I always do the work alongside the students as examples for them to understand what we are working on, so I used my design page for this first go at analysing designs so they felt ok about saying what they thought about it.

I put up my design page, with number on each design so they could decide which one they wanted to analyse. I also  gave them a list of questions that they had to answer in the comment section of the blog post. I have colour coded the questions here to show how i use SOLO Taxonomy to structure the questions to have an increasing level of thought and depth.

1. Which number design are you going to be analysing?
2. Which architect do you think this design was based on?
3. Which part of the design links to the architect’s design elements the most?
4. Do you think this design is suitable for the place that it is designed for? if yes, say why you think it is, and if no, say why you don’t think it is.
5. How would you improve this design?  – you are not allowed to say you wouldn’t change it as everything can be improved.

The students coped really well with their first try at this and their answers were showing analytical thinking and knowledge of the work we have been doing with the designer research.

Link to blog post - scroll down to see the students comments.